Less succinctly, “Why does anyone write, but we know I can’t factually answer that outside of relating what my own motivations are.”
What I can do, however, is what so many of us love to do: speculate.
Now, I’m writing this post in response to what my fellow author, Audrey Driscoll, posted on “Writing Without Publishing?” which is in itself a response to Kevin Brennan’s post, “Is Publication the Be-All and End-All For Writers?” I heartily suggest reading both since they stimulated my mind to think about this topic — something a good blog post often does.
Originally, I was about to type a comment to Audrey’s post focusing on why writers write in terms of publishing or not, but, as so often happens, my mind started to go down several paths only to double back upon realizing that it might be best to zoom out and view the question at a much higher level.
So why do we write? The first, simplest answer that comes to mind is, “To communicate.” But is that truly the root reason? If it were, how do we categorize Kevin Brennan’s desire to write strictly for himself? It’s a legitimate take on writing, so here’s where I zoom out a bit.
Writing isn’t a single-purpose process. It evolved as a solution to a number of human needs. Writing is a means of communication. Writing is a means of expression, an artform. Writing is a means of relieving a memory load by recording information for later retrieval. Writing is a skilled profession. There may be other drivers, but my brain seems happy enough at the moment with these four. That is, it’s sufficient for a blog post as opposed to a treatise.
Looking at those four building blocks, you can create a number of combinations which might apply to any given person at a given time. While all drivers may be true, some will carry more weight given the circumstance. Think of Medieval calligraphers who weren’t creating the content to communicate, but were using their artistic skills in some form of employment (expression, profession). Journalists are primarily combining communication, profession, and recording. Authors, well I’ve often stated that authors exist along a scale between expression and profession with communication being strongly desired, but less essential the closer you get to the expression side of the scale (as in Brennan’s case). And I could go on with a variety of examples to cover a broad scope of writers’ endeavors.
Interestingly, you can ascribe the same four drivers to the visual arts. Cave paintings — possibly the earliest artform — have been shown to exhibit the need to express, communicate and record. Imprints of hands and abstract patterns were likely means of self-expression. Depictions of animal and scenes of a hunt were useful as communication tools for learning, as well as a visual record of events. One can speculate, if you were good at it, then that would be a role you’d have in your tribe/clan (satisfying profession). Now, writing evolved from primitive visual arts, in some cases as imagery simplified into pictograms, in others as easy to draw symbols representing phonetic sounds. So the relationship of visual arts to words is extremely close and I always keep that in mind when considering discussions on my chosen craft.
I feel it’s important to make this association because I have run into visual artists and musicians who use their craft purely for the creational aspect of art. Sometimes this creative act is a personal exploration to find something new or relatable, sometimes as a means of catharsis. In both cases, an audience is unnecessary and often undesirable. Writing used as an artform can be no different in this respect.
Of course, if you are on the other end of the expression/profession scale, while you are definitely crafting an artistic output — often pouring your heart and soul into your work — the end product needs to generate income. We all have to eat. Traveling on that route means seeking to be published, leading to compromise, deadlines and a host of other demands true of pretty much every profession. But, as in any profession, if you love what you’re doing, the constraints tend to melt away or at least diminish to the occasional annoyance.
So, I wonder for any writer who might read this post, have you ever contemplated the “why” of doing what you do? If so, are these four components a sufficient starting point? I also wonder which one/ones tend to carry the most weight. Whatever the answers, I am reasonably certain that every writer is driven by some mix of the four but it’s really the assigned weight of each component that differentiates us.
And why do I write?
I’ve answered this one before, pretty consistently. For me it’s the craft derived from the combination of (primarily) communication followed by expression: storytelling. I’ve always admired the adept raconteur who manages to elevate a mundane anecdote to a level where people are listening with rapt attention. I’ve also loved the storytellers who, like the ancients gathered around a campfire, ignite the imagination with legends and lore. Lord knows, these modern equivalents have done that to me. Unlike the ancient oral storytellers, authors driven by the need to tell a story lack the visual feedback of a listener. So, we throw our tales out there in the hopes that they reach someone. And that’s exactly what I do — and why I do it.

Great answers to the question, Richard!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thank you 😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
You’re welcome. 😎
LikeLiked by 1 person
I like your analytical approach to the question, Richard. For writers who don’t need to make a living from their writing, it comes down to expression first. To communicate, you need to publish in some way. Publishing is also a way of recording your expression so as to communicate with people of the future. I think this way of thinking about writing gives each of us a set of questions we can ask ourselves about our intentions and expectations.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Exactly. Publishing is the primary (only, I guess) road to communication if that factors into your drive, and there’s no way around it if writing is to be a source of income.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Great post. I don’t think too much about why I write; I just do it because I want to and I get satisfaction out of it. I hope to make a profession and money out of it when I started, but now I’m happy just doing it for the joy of it. I guess a question for me would be, why do some people not write? It’s having the ability to analyse, to organise, to invent, in a particular way; some of us have it and some not. That’ll do for me. 🙂
LikeLike